
The Cost of Believing Everything Is Terrible
What happens when anger and misinformation become the lens through which you see your life.
This morning I watched a video of Jamil Jivani giving a speech about how Canada has been destroyed. How the Liberal government has taken everything from Canadians. How people who speak out shouldn’t be called traitors.
There was a lot of anger, a lot of big statements, and absolutely no shortage of people in his comments agreeing with every word.
Canada is broken. They’ve destroyed everything. Look what they’ve done to us.
And I just kept thinking, what exactly are you seeing that I’m not?
Because I live here too.
I’m not saying everything is great. Jesus Christ. Have you been to the grocery store lately? Housing is a disaster in a lot of this country. People are struggling. Healthcare has serious problems. I have plenty of opinions about our governments, at every level.
The kicker is, I also lost my job.
My income has changed dramatically over the past year. I’m figuring out what the hell I’m doing next. There are days when I worry about money and the future and whether I’m making the right decisions.
So it’s not like I’m sitting here in some magical bubble where everything is perfect and I just don’t understand why everyone is so upset.
What I don’t understand is how being upset about real problems became the same thing as believing that everything is destroyed.
Because when I look around, I don’t see a destroyed country.
Sure, I see a country with problems. A country that has changed. A country dealing with the fallout of a pandemic that changed the ENTIRE world. A country that made some good decisions and some bad ones. A country where people are struggling in ways they weren’t struggling ten or twenty years ago.
But that’s different from believing Canada is broken.
People have seriously lost the ability to tell the difference.
Maybe that’s what bothers me so much about these professional rage farmers who build entire careers around being angry.
They find something that is real. Something people are genuinely worried about. The cost of living. Housing. Jobs. Healthcare. And then they take that thing and stretch it as far as it will go.
Things are expensive becomes they destroyed the economy.
The healthcare system is struggling becomes Canada is a failed country.
You don’t like a government policy becomes the government is your enemy.
Someone disagrees with you becomes they’re brainwashed.
And before you know it, everything is proof that somebody is coming for you.
Your country. Your money. Your kids. Your freedom. Whatever.
And honestly, that sounds fucking exhausting.
Imagine waking up every day believing that everything around you is falling apart. That the government is lying to you. The media is lying to you. The schools are lying to you. The doctors are lying to you. Your neighbours are the problem. People who disagree with you are idiots or woke or whatever derogatory word we’re using this week.
What kind of life is that?
What does believing all of this actually do to your quality of life?
Not what does inflation do to your quality of life. Obviously, that’s real.
Not what does losing your job do to your quality of life. Also very fucking real.
I’m talking about what happens when you take every difficult thing happening in your life and place it inside a story that says everything is terrible, everyone is against you, and there is no reason to believe anything will get better.
That’s a different thing.
Two people can be living through the exact same situation and experience it completely differently.
One person says, “Shit is hard right now. But let’s look at the big picture. Get some historical context. I can see how we ended up here. Now let’s work together to get where we want to go.”
The other person says, “This is proof that the liberals destroyed everything. I wnat to go back to a different time and can’t accept change or nuance. ”
Those aren’t just different political opinions.
That’s where misinformation becomes so much more than just people believing things that aren’t true.
It becomes a worldview.
You don’t just believe one thing you saw on Facebook that turned out to be bullshit. You start seeing the world through a lens that has already decided what everything means.
The grocery store is expensive. Proof Canada is broken.
There’s a long wait at the hospital. More proof. (Although, you can take this up with your provincial conservative gov.)
You see someone speaking a different language. The horror!
The government spends money on something you don’t agree with. Elites!
A Pride flag exists somewhere. Wokeism this. Purple hair that.
Everything becomes another piece of evidence in a story you already believe.
And the people telling you that story are very happy to keep giving you more.
That’s what makes me rage.
There are people who have figured out that anger is profitable.
They know people are scared. They know people are struggling. They know people feel like things have changed too quickly and they don’t understand why their lives don’t look the way they thought they would.
Those are real concerns.
But instead of helping people understand what’s happening, they give them someone to blame. (See my post about the Finkelstein Formula.)
They don’t have to offer solutions. In fact, solutions are kind of beside the point.
It’s much easier to say, look what they did to you.
It’s much easier to point at someone and say, that’s the reason your life is hard.
And if someone questions the story, well, they’re part of the problem too.
I think that’s why I have such a hard time watching these speeches and reading the comments underneath them.
There are hundreds of people cheering each other on about how terrible everything is, and I want to grab them by the shoulders and say, but what is actually happening in your life right now?
Not what did someone tell you is happening.
What is actually happening?
Because yes, my life changed when I lost my job. And yes, I could spend a lot of time figuring out who to blame for that.
I could blame the federal government. I could blame the provincial government. I could blame immigration policies. I could blame the college. I could blame COVID.
And honestly, depending on how badly I wanted to tell the story, I could probably make a pretty convincing case for any of them.
But I also know the truth is more complicated.
COVID happened.
The world changed.
Governments made decisions that had consequences.
Some of those consequences were good. Some were bad. Some helped people. Some hurt people. Some decisions were probably necessary at the time and don’t look so great in hindsight.
That’s life.
That’s also government.
It’s messy.
I guess that’s part of the problem too. Reality is fucking complicated, and people really seem to prefer a simple story.
Without nuance, you don’t have to think about an insane president with expansionist fantasies, a global pandemic, supply chains, inflation, housing speculation, provincial responsibilities, corporate greed, or any of the other things that might have contributed to where we are now.
You have a villain.
And villains are useful.
They give you somewhere to put your anger.
I think what scares me is how much of our actual experience of life can be shaped by the stories we’re constantly consuming about it.
If you spend every day reading and watching people tell you that Canada is falling apart, eventually you’re going to start looking around for evidence that it’s true.
And you’ll find it.
You can always find evidence that things are terrible.
There are terrible things happening all over the place. There always have been.
But you can also find evidence that things are good.
People helping each other. Neighbours looking after neighbours. People falling in love. Friends having dinner. Families taking trips. Someone getting the job they really wanted. Someone recovering from something difficult. Someone deciding to start over.
Or how about a bunch of people on the internet deciding to spend 21 days doing weird & whimsical little things because joy is resistance?
All of that is happening too.
But I don’t think the people making money from your anger are at all interested in reminding you of that.
Hope doesn’t get people as worked up. Perspective doesn’t make great rage bait.
And “things are complicated and we should probably work together to figure some of this out” is not exactly going to get a thousand people retweeting your bullshit
So here we are.
Living in the same country and somehow experiencing completely different versions of it.
I don’t think being hopeful means being naive. I don’t think being able to see good things means you’re ignoring the bad ones. And I definitely don’t think we should stop criticizing governments or politicians or systems that aren’t working.
But I do think we need to be careful about who is benefiting from our anger.
I think we need to ask ourselves whether the story we’re being told about our lives actually matches the life we’re living.
Because sure, Canada has problems.
My life has problems.
Your life probably has problems too.
But that doesn’t automatically mean everything is terrible.
BUT there are a lot of people out there who need us to believe that it is.



